<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=2849132&amp;fmt=gif">

Solution Comparison

The Modern NAC Alternative for Zero Trust Security

 

While NAC projects stall in complexity, Elisity deploys in weeks using existing infrastructure — stopping lateral movement without the pain of 802.1X, VLANs, or endless ACLs.

NAC Controls Access.

Elisity Controls What Happens Next.

NAC promised control but delivered complexity — years of setup, 14+ FTEs, VLAN sprawl, and still no protection from lateral movement. Elisity delivers identity-based microsegmentation in weeks using your existing infrastructure, with no agents or downtime.

Capability

Link

Traditional NAC

Deployment Time

2 weeks average from deployment to first policy

Complicated multi-year deployments, difficult 6 months planning + up to 6 years globally

Downtime Required

Zero downtime deployments

Yes - Constant change windows

What It Controls

Lateral movement (continuous)

Network access (authentication)

Network Redesign

None - No network config changes needed

Required - VLAN and ACL sprawl

Agent Requirement

Agentless - Works with any device

Agents and 802.1X supplicants required

IoT/OT Support

Full support - Agentless approach

Limited - Highly complex and brittle

Zero Trust

Complete - Identity-based continuous control

Partial - Authentication only

Deployment Time

2 weeks average from deployment to first policy

Downtime Required

Zero downtime deployments

What It Controls

Lateral movement (continuous)

Network Redesign

None - No network config changes needed

Agent Requirement

Agentless - Works with any device

IoT/OT Support

Full support - Agentless approach

Zero Trust

Complete - Identity-based continuous control

Deployment Time

Complicated multi-year deployments, difficult 6 months planning + up to 6 years globally

Downtime Required

Yes - Constant change windows

What It Controls

Network access (authentication)

Network Redesign

Required - VLAN and ACL sprawl

Agent Requirement

Agents and 802.1X supplicants required

IoT/OT Support

Limited - Highly complex and brittle

Zero Trust

Partial - Authentication only

Why CISOs, SecOps, and Network Teams Are Moving Beyond NAC

The Problem

Legacy NAC projects drag on, demand hardware, VLAN changes, and on-site teams — causing costly delays and threat exposure in downtime.

The Elisity Advantage

Deploy in weeks with zero downtime—no hardware, no 802.1X, no VLANs, and no site visits required.

The Outcome

Faster rollouts, lower costs, and agile segmentation that delivers security without the complexity.

The Problem

Multiple consoles and tools create silos, blind spots, and wasted hours managing policies across systems.

The Elisity Advantage

Single cloud UX console for discovery, segmentation, and enforcement—real-time visibility across every site. Plus 25+ integrations with Elisity IdentityGraph™.

The Outcome

Unified control, faster response, and simplified compliance with automated insights and reporting.

The Problem

NAC demands constant firefighting and creates a console sprawl nightmare — authentication issues, agent updates, endless change windows, and manual synchronization leaves gaps.

The Elisity Advantage

Amplify your existing FTEs with optimized and automated classification, policy simulation, and centralized management.

The Outcome

Free your team to focus on strategic Zero Trust initiatives, not troubleshooting.

The Problem

NAC checks credentials at the door but can’t stop what happens inside.

The Elisity Advantage

Continuous, identity-based microsegmentation prevents lateral movement across all users, devices, and applications. Elisity IdentityGraph™ maintains context as devices roam with static or dynamic identity-based policies.

The Outcome

Address the 70% of breaches NAC ignores — and finally deliver on Zero Trust.

Speed to Value

The Problem

Legacy NAC projects drag on, demand hardware, VLAN changes, and on-site teams — causing costly delays and threat exposure in downtime.

The Elisity Advantage

Deploy in weeks with zero downtime—no hardware, no 802.1X, no VLANs, and no site visits required.

The Outcome

Faster rollouts, lower costs, and agile segmentation that delivers security without the complexity.

Unified Control

The Problem

Multiple consoles and tools create silos, blind spots, and wasted hours managing policies across systems.

The Elisity Advantage

Single cloud UX console for discovery, segmentation, and enforcement—real-time visibility across every site. Plus 25+ integrations with Elisity IdentityGraph™.

The Outcome

Unified control, faster response, and simplified compliance with automated insights and reporting.

Operational Efficiency

The Problem

NAC demands constant firefighting and creates a console sprawl nightmare — authentication issues, agent updates, endless change windows, and manual synchronization leaves gaps.

The Elisity Advantage

Amplify your existing FTEs with optimized and automated classification, policy simulation, and centralized management.

The Outcome

Free your team to focus on strategic Zero Trust initiatives, not troubleshooting.

Complete Security, Everywhere

The Problem

NAC checks credentials at the door but can’t stop what happens inside.

The Elisity Advantage

Continuous, identity-based microsegmentation prevents lateral movement across all users, devices, and applications. Elisity IdentityGraph™ maintains context as devices roam with static or dynamic identity-based policies.

The Outcome

Address the 70% of breaches NAC ignores — and finally deliver on Zero Trust.

Real Customers, Real Proof

“We made more progress in 2 days with Elisity than 2 years trying to implement NAC.”

Bryan Holmes
Director of IT Security, Andelyn Biosciences

"After two years of NAC failures, Elisity had us enforcing policy within weeks.”

Gene Therapy Manufacturer

What You Get With Elisity

2

Number of Weeks from Deployment to First Policy Applied

85%

Less Specialized Resources Required

75%

Cost Reduction

0

Downtime Across 100% of Deployments

From NAC Fatigue to Zero Trust Confidence

Elisity doesn't need to be a rip-and-replace. It complements NAC where it falls short.

  • Keep NAC for authentication.
  • Use Elisity for continuous least privilege access policies to prevent lateral-movement.
  • Go at your own pace — no downtime, no re-architecture.

Network Asset Control FAQ

Want to know how Elisity discovers every device across your network — even the ones your current tools miss? Here are answers to common questions about asset visibility, classification, and what makes Elisity’s approach unique.

What is the difference between NAC and microsegmentation?

NAC (Network Access Control) controls who gets on your network by authenticating devices at the perimeter using 802.1X or RADIUS. Microsegmentation controls what devices can communicate with after they're on the network by enforcing identity-based policies at every connection point. While NAC provides perimeter security, microsegmentation prevents lateral movement—the attack vector used in 70% of successful breaches. Elisity's identity-based microsegmentation works alongside existing NAC solutions or replaces them entirely, deploying in 2 weeks versus 3-12 months for traditional NAC implementations. 

How long does it take to deploy network access control compared to microsegmentation?

Traditional NAC deployments typically require 3-12 months involving hardware procurement, 802.1X configuration, VLAN redesigns, and multi-team coordination. Elisity's microsegmentation deploys in 2 weeks. We can turn switches, WLCs, Firewalls into enforcement points. Day 1 focuses on cloud provisioning and Virtual Edge software deployment. Day 2 enables visibility and first security least privilage access security policies. Within 1 week, you can achieve full policy enforcement across all sites—a 75% reduction in deployment time compared to legacy NAC approaches. 

Why do NAC projects fail or stall in enterprises?

NAC projects fail due to complexity, resource constraints, and scope creep. Enterprises struggle with 802.1X authentication issues, VLAN sprawl, ACL management at scale, and the need for 14+ FTEs across Security Ops, Network Engineering, and platform management teams. Integration challenges with heterogeneous infrastructure (mixing Cisco, Aruba, Juniper, Arista, Hirshmann) create deployment bottlenecks. Additionally, NAC only controls perimeter access—it doesn't prevent lateral movement once attackers authenticate, leaving organizations vulnerable despite the investment. 76% of enterprises using NAC report adoption has plateaued due to these operational challenges. 

Can microsegmentation work with existing NAC solutions?

Yes, Elisity's microsegmentation complements existing NAC deployments. NAC handles authentication and initial network access, while Elisity enforces continuous identity-based policies that prevent lateral movement after devices authenticate. This layered approach maximizes your NAC investment while addressing its fundamental limitation—lack of east-west traffic control. Organizations can deploy Elisity alongside NAC solutions without replacing infrastructure, or gradually transition from NAC to Elisity's identity-based approach as a complete network access control alternative. The integration requires no changes to your NAC configuration. 

When should an organization replace NAC with microsegmentation?

Replace NAC when projects stall beyond 6 months, operational costs exceed 10+ FTEs, or lateral movement concerns outweigh perimeter control needs. Organizations should transition when facing NAC deployment complexity with 802.1X, VLAN limitations, or multi-vendor infrastructure incompatibility. If your network includes significant IoT/OT devices that can't support NAC agents or supplicants, microsegmentation provides better coverage. Consider replacement when pursuing Zero Trust architecture, as microsegmentation natively supports continuous verification versus NAC's point-in-time authentication model. Elisity can complement existing NAC initially, then replace it as your primary access control solution. 

How much does NAC cost compared to identity-based microsegmentation?

Traditional NAC total cost of ownership includes software licenses, hardware appliances, 14+ FTE operational staff, and 3-12 month deployment professional services. Enterprises typically spend $500K-$2M+ annually depending on scale. Elisity's microsegmentation reduces operational overhead by 75%, requiring only 2 FTEs for management, and deploys in weeks versus months—significantly lowering professional services costs. Elisity is cloud-delivered with no hardware requirements, eliminating capital expenditure on appliances. Organizations typically see ROI within 6-9 months through reduced staffing needs, faster deployment, and prevention of costly breach-related lateral movement (average breach cost: $4.45M). 

Back to top

Take the Next Step

Visibility, control, and protection — without the pain.

Schedule a technical deep-dive with our solutions team


Why NAC Projects Stall: The Hidden Technical Complexities and NAC Alternatives Reshaping Network Security
NAC Alternative Planning

Why NAC Projects Stall: The Hidden Technical Complexities and NAC Alternatives Reshaping Network Security

Dec 3, 2025 11:39:12 AM 9 min read
Elisity Release 16.14: Network Traffic Analytics That Actually Help You Make Decisions
Elisity Release 16.14 Network Traffic Analytics

Elisity Release 16.14: Network Traffic Analytics That Actually Help You Make Decisions

Nov 24, 2025 10:55:35 AM 3 min read
Cybersecurity Budget Benchmarks for 2026: Essential Planning Guide for Enterprise Security Leaders
Network Engineer

Cybersecurity Budget Benchmarks for 2026: Essential Planning Guide for Enterprise Security Leaders

Nov 13, 2025 3:09:55 PM 18 min read